Patient Media

« Monday Morning Motivation | Main | Monday Morning Motivation »

Saving Chiropractic

Can chiropractic be saved?I was awakened from a deep sleep by a text message from a trusted leader in the chiropractic profession this morning.

"Can we chat?"

"Sure," I sleepily tapped out.

Soon the phone rang. After the pleasantries were exchanged, I ask why the urgency of such an early morning call.

"We've got a lot of chiropractors who are going broke," he practically whispered. "Reimbursement is getting less and less and there's a whole bunch of doctors wondering how they're going to make next month's rent. I've gotta help turn this thing around. So, I'm calling you for some ideas. Can you help?"

"I'll try," I replied, still without my first cup of coffee. "I'm keenly aware of this problem. It's the one thing I've been thinking about, talking about and writing about for the last couple of months."

"So, what's the answer?" he asked eagerly.

"The problem is, many chiropractors have 'eaten their seed corn.' So they don't have much margin to accomplish the changes they need to make," I said stating the obvious.

"That's probably true, but it is what it is," he admitted. "I need some solutions."

Apparently my colleague was demanding a checklist of things that chiropractors could implement this afternoon that would restore their chiropractic practices to a place they were a decade or two ago. Oh, and one more thing, make it snappy!

Can't be done. And few seem interested in the reasons the profession is in its current state. However, the way out of this mess is a reversal of the way we got in. Think of it as a form of professional "retracing."

Step One: Take an Inventory

You can't leave a place you've never admitted to having been. So the first task is to get a lay of the land and create a clear assessment of the situation. Because until you can clearly articulate (and accept) what the problem is, solutions will remain elusive. You want to make sure you have identified the real problem and not a convenient proxy. Such as these:

1. Not enough new patients.
2. Too many chiropractors.
3. Reduced reimbursement from third parties.
4. A lack of scientific evidence proving chiropractic.
5. The economy.
6. Need to enlarging the scope of chiropractic.
7. Integrate chiropractic into the health care mainstream.
Based upon your preferred hammer, you might go after one or more of these nails. But these are all distractions that would keep you busy, but wouldn't get you any closer to actually solving the problem facing individual practitioners.

If any of these convenient excuses were true, how do you explain the fact that some chiropractic practices are booming? Having their best year ever? How do you pin your hopes on one of these seven when some chiropractors are helping lots of patients? In your state. In this economy. It would seem to disqualify the victim mentality, finger pointing and acquired helplessness exhibited by many who are struggling.

So, what's the real problem?

The problem isn't "out there." The problem resides within the cerebral cortex of the chiropractor. Between the ears. What they think is true but isn't. The subluxation above the atlas. In a word: headspace.

Step Two: Replace the Lies With the Truth

Changing headspace is far more difficult than implementing a new procedure, reciting a new script or establishing a new policy. Changing someone's thinking is a most wonderfully difficult thing to do. You may have noticed this as you've attempted to change a patient's way of thinking. Same thing here.

That's partly because most patients don't visit a chiropractor in the hopes of having their worldview changed. Similarly, most chiropractors, even those who are struggling, aren't exactly open to a mind shift. Instead, they want success on their terms. Instead of changing the position of their sails, they wait for the wind to change.

Long wait.

One such wind, actually just a faint breeze, is the hope that national health care reform will somehow save their practice. It won't. There are at least seven reasons why Obama Care won't help you.

But what has even greater implications is the beliefs chiropractors have about chiropractic. Many of the chiropractors I speak with who are struggling have great clinical skills, but have a distorted idea about what chiropractic is and what it isn't. They have made it in their own image, making chiropractic fit their particular skill set or perspective. They have the "doing" of chiropractic down pat. But they lack clarity about where chiropractic ends and medicine begins. Blur this boundary and you not only reduce chiropractic to a spinal therapy for a limited range of neuromuscular-skeletal conditions, you end up assuming blame when your adjustments don't seem to "work." Because even if you don't think your adjustments are treating their headaches, the patient does and their insurance carrier demands it.

And that's a huge problem. Most chiropractic practices in the profession have created a legacy of being perceived as neck and back pain specialists who expect to be paid by insurance carriers.

Even more troubling is a more subtle belief held by chiropractors who aren't sure they offer a service valuable enough that a patient would reach into their own pocket or purse to pay for.

Step Three: Begin

So, what is the solution?

1. Admit the current reimbursement trends are unlikely to reverse. In fact, they are likely to get worse.

2. Accept that you cannot look to an outside entity to rescue you. Especially not the government. And certainly not the prospect that insurance companies will suddenly become enlightened and value chiropractic care appropriately.

3. Communicate chiropractic principles with clarity, confidence and certainty. Make sure every patient understands that you aren't treating their ache or pain, but rather reviving their ability to self heal.

4. Time to go to the mattresses. Reduce your personal overhead to bare minimums. Make sure every staff member understands what's at stake and get him or her on board. Reduce your practice overhead where possible.

5. Begin the process of slowly discontinuing taking insurance assignment. Pick the carrier for whom you have the least number of patients using and give those patients notification that in 90 days you will no longer be taking assignment. Work your way up the list over the course of a year or so. Begin the process of converting to cash. Go slow!

6. Make chiropractic care attractive to people who value their health enough to pay for it and not expect reimbursement.
I know. Not especially sexy. Or easy. Or quick. But you have to decide whether you love chiropractic enough to fight for it.

Remember back in the day when virtually any practice problem could be solved by getting more new patients? The old solutions aren't going to work. But you're going to have to want it. Want it bad.

Do you?

Bookmark and Share

Comments (5)

Bill Laughlin:

I disagree that chiropractic lacks enough scientific evidence. We ARE compiling more, but what amount is ever going to be "sufficient" for acceptance into the medical system? Answer: never enough...the goalposts will remain in constant motion away from us.

The best recent article addressing this was Don Petersen's "The War is Not Over" in a recent Dynamic Chiropractic. Despite worldwide acknowledgement, we are totally ignored in U.S. medical templates. Regardless of the actual reason(s) we have a completely different paradigm: vitalism vs. atomism (Dean Black).

I'd also remind folks that medheads often ignore their own "research" whenever convenient (chemotherapy) and this is attested to in the aforementioned Petersen article BY a medical researcher/author.

We may not be able to change the prevailing "wisdom" in our lifetimes, but we CAN do the best to adjust our patients, for the right reasons, and stay up on our own education (thanks, Bill E.)

Indeed, chiropractic is not yet fully recognized in the medical community because it lacks scientific evidence. The profession is somehow bound to collapse because of this. If only they have more evidences to support the claims and that there are live experiments proving their effectiveness, this profession could have been recognized and perhaps will become more popular.

Evan Hughes:

I've been a cash practice since I started 8 years ago. The most important thing I did recently to grow was get under care by someone more successful then I. It's one thing to talk about how a cash practice can work, and even have some success with it. It's another thing to see and experience it working with someone else. I found it silenced a lot of negative self talk I had to be getting adjusted in an environment like I wanted to create. The day insurance stops covering chiropractic care is the day my practice triples! I just hope there will be others around to enjoy the success with me.

Cate:

Thank You! and... its about patient education and not picking on insurance reimbursement. We need to educate every patient that comes into our doors about what we can do for them, and why they should chose us first. I currently work in a practice that does not accept insurance (not my choice, I'm an associate) and it kills me how many patients walk out the door when they realize that we are not in network with their insurance. I wish I could have each of those patients back because the truth is, we can't expect the insurance company to pay for every teeny tiny problem and damage to their nervous system they have experienced since birth. Insurance companies were created to get a patient stable, able to work and able to survive their current pain and predicament. So we got ourselves into the system, now we need to educate everyone why we belong in it! I'm not defending insurance companies, but its not that simple to expect them to just switch to "preventative" medicine.

Step 1: get the patients into the door
Step 2: educate them about why chiropractic works and how it should be used for more than their primary "back pain" complaint and CAN be used for those other problems they are experiencing.
Step 3: get patient out of pain, back to where they were, and then transition them to a cash patient/preventative care patient.

I'm new to the profession and I still have not seen all the amazing things that chiropractic can do. Heck, I'm still doubtful that what I do will always work. But I can see that our profession does not have it together to fight against the US healthcare system.

Jeff:

I couldn't agree more and can't understand why the chiropractic profession isn't trying to get out of insurance and/or Obamacare. I have a few friends in New Zealand and Australia who have thriving practices because people want something that works and don't mind paying for it. People pay cash for acupuncturists and massage therapists and if those professions started down the insurance path (which I think they are trying) they would or will soon be in the same mess our professions is. I think our profession has a ton of fear and doubt. Our profession needs to take a leap of faith, and our colleges need to stop putting our future chiropractor's in a ton of debt!!!

Post a comment

(If you haven't left a comment here before, you may need to be approved by the site owner before your comment will appear. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

From January 8, 2013 5:25 PM

This page contains a single entry from the blog posted on January 8, 2013 5:25 PM.

The previous post in this blog was Monday Morning Motivation.

The next post in this blog is Monday Morning Motivation.

Many more can be found on the main index page or by looking through the archives.